Cardiff Blues – The Downward Spiral

There were some desperate sweaty palms on display in Cardiff Blues corners this week, as yet another star looked set to part ways with the crises club. The fear element for the Cardiff Blues though must be that now one of their young guns, Grand Slam winner Alex Cuthbert, looks to have packed his bag. Previously it was a case of the aging foreigners and light weight Welsh journeyman quota who seemed to be lining up to walk out of the city centre, but now the future of the Blues seems to be following the present away from the club as well.

 For Welsh rugby fans, the loss of the likes of Dan Parks, Ritchie Rees and Rhys Thomas will see few tears shed, and while Lauala is no doubt a star, he is a foreign star blocking a starting spot for a Welsh player, another departure which in itself is not an entirely bad thing. Sounds coming out of the Blues management should also have given reason to be reassured, after all, a commitment from the club to follow a ‘home grown’ path, similar to that develop by the Scarlets, should be welcomed. However, no sooner had the Blues announced such intentions, they did what they have done so well over recent years, flown in some very average foreigners.

 Campese Ma’afu, the Fijian forward to have the briefest of international careers, and star of the English second tier Robin Copeland were the names announced last week as replacements for Lions and All Black internationals… Now, the Blues as with all Welsh teams don’t really have the money to be bringing in the southern hemisphere superstars, however, in Ma’afu and Copeland, the Blues have ‘invested’ in two non Welsh qualified players, who have never shown the star capabilities to inspire young Welsh talent at the club to go on to be anything more than mediocre.

 For Alex Cuthbert, no one in Wales would blame him for leaving. This is in part an issue of money, but far from entirely. We know Cuthbert was offered a substantial figure by a Blues management desperate to appear to be doing their bit to ‘save’ Welsh talent, but for all the money put in front of him, surely Cuthbert can see that this is a club that has, in a very definitive fashion, set its stall out to be an average side, and no more. The recent on field capitulations have shown this all too clearly. Say what you will of the future, last week the Blues were fighting for a shot at a European title and a place in the Pro12 play-offs in the present…they surrendered both opportunities in such a manner that you’d be justified in asking why they turned up in the first place.

 Balancing the books is one thing, but curbing ambition is quite another. If the Blues commit to the current policy of bolstering a depleted squad with the rejects of the lower divisions of English rugby, the concept of ‘holding on’ to their Welsh stars will rapidly become irrelevant, as the Welsh stars won’t be bother bring to be held on to in the first place.

  1. My sympathies, Eyeonwales! However, that does make me think about a book (which was made into a movie), “Moneyball.” The sport in question was baseball, and maybe that’s a different thing altogether, but the premise was that the team managers were bringing it what appeared to be “the rejects,” yet there was a methodology to the team they were building. They got a lot of flack from fans and sports announcers, etc, but they did end up with a winning formula. Maybe it doesn’t apply to the Blues, but then again….? Just a thought!

    • Indeed, it is a policy that has worked for some in the past – the Ospreys in west Wales did a great job of using above average southern hemisphere players at the end of their career to serve as the backbone for local youth development. Alas those coming in for the Blues are very much on the wrong side of average. We can hope for their success…we can do little more, but we can hope for them.

    • Neil
    • April 17th, 2012

    I have to say that this season has been particularly tough to watch. Whilst regional rugby as a whole is struggling, the Blues seems to be suffering more than most.

    Next season could be very painful to watch – especially if they continue to insist on playing games at the ghost town that is the CCS.

    • Indeed, whatever agreement they have lumbered themselves with on that stadium needs to be broken as soon as possible. Watching Cardiff in the city centre always had the makings of a great afternoon or evening. To visit the CCS has no such comparisons, unless of course you want to get the weekend shopping in at the same time…not quite what you might aim for on a visit to a top flight rugby match.

      A return to the centre of Cardiff would go some way to encouraging the fans to come and watch, which would be a good starting point in terms of any financial planning. Somebody at that club really needs to own up, and say ‘we got it wrong’.

        • Neil
        • April 19th, 2012

        Given that both fixtures at CAP drew above average crowds for what were considered pretty unimportant games, you’d think they’d get the message. I think there’s a lot of politics being played behind closed doors and it’s annoying because it feels like decisions are being made to the detriment of the club and its supporters.

        Rumours are abound that a large proportion of games will be played at CAP next season – I really hope this is true. With a lot of big names leaving the team for new pastures, they’ll need to do something to keep people coming through the turn styles.

  2. Agreed, there is an obvious central city based crowd that is eager to watch games. To reunite crowd and team must be seen as the key step to any future ambitions for the region, the Arms Park, rusty and weathered as it may look, is essential for that.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: